2018 Mid Year Report Card: Collingwood

With Collingwood enjoying their week off, what better time to pass judgement on their season to date. How did they fare on The Pinch Hitters Mid Year Report Card?

In the eyes of the football world, Collingwood entered the 2018 season with a coach under pressure and plenty of question marks over the list. While there may be a few questions unanswered the pressure surrounding Nathan Buckley at the dawn of the season is all but gone after his teams eight and four start. As the Magpies take their well-earned mid-season break what are to make of their season to date?



Is it too simple to say that they have found a way to win? Rounding out an eight win start to the season with a statement victory over the in-form Dees was probably as close to the perfect scenario for Nathan Buckley at the mid-season break. Along the way they have unearthed a few gems, including the fast developing. Mason Cox, and are proving themselves to be thereabouts and improving as the year goes on.

The highlight of Collingwood’s season to date still may well be their Round Four victory over the Crows in Adelaide. It was so good that the question was asked whether it was better than beating Carlton. Read our Fan Sided take on the game here: Collingwood Commentary: Is that better than beating Carlton?













It is hard to find much to fault in Collingwood’s impressive start to 2018, perhaps an injury list that has gotten a little out of hand. A couple of losses in games that didn’t need losing against Geelong and Hawthorn, when they strayed somewhat from the formula that has served them so well, might also prove costly in the jockeying for top four or top eight positions at seasons end.



Has really made a difference where it matters in the opening rounds of the season. Has developed into an elite ruckman giving his midfielders first use of the ball, as one of the top 20 clearance winners in the competition, that is ofcourse when he is not following it up himself. No lumbering dinosaur of a ruckman he is also damaging around the ground too, he is in the competitions top 25 when it comes to contested marks too.


There are 6 games that we SHOULD win with the rest all a possibility if we play Pies footy. With this in mind a final position anywhere from second to eighth remains a real possibility. My Guess? Collingwood will finish fourth.


Report Card

Hi! Can you do us a favour and like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter? Don’t hesitate to send us feedback or comment below if you think we are talking rubbish. Or if we’re not.


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: